.. [interlude]
A letter, tucked between the pages of an anthology of Plato's writings, stained in places with ink and a single ring of red wine.
Dearest Edmund,
Forgive me for saying so, but yours was not the most difficult death to swallow. And yet, the implications of what came after are the hardest for me to accept.
We were never the favorites, you and I. That was Lucy, with her fair shining hair and her reputation as the Valiant; that was Peter, who was the eldest andfor some reason regarded as the most reliable. I know now that you spent fifteen-and-ten years trying to make up for betraying us once, as a child. I spent the same time too nervous and uncertain to truly commit to anything. And so you were called Just, and I was called Gentle, and we never quite measured up, did we? It didn't matter all that much to me when you all were alive, but now, sometimes, I think back, and I wonder if I mightn't have forgotten so quickly if I hadn't felt forgotten.
Oh, but that's not the point of this letter, is it? There's no need to point fingers. Let's see: In your honor, I am trying to be more stubborn. I think I might be succeeding. I believe ██████████████ ███████████████████ █████████████████████ █████████████████, but as it turns out, I had it in me all along.
Lucy visited! Several months ago now. I do hope she told you. I do hope she hasn't forgotten. The picture she painted of Aslan's country was- I haven't the words to describe my reaction, but it seems as if earthly cares, like your dear living sister, mightn't be at the forefront of your mind any more. If she told you, then you'll know now that I've remembered everything about Narnia. I'm sorry to you in particular that I forgot for so long - and you know how I am about apologies. On the one hand, I do wish I could have remembered before you died, so that we could have spoken about it together without fighting. On the other hand, I'm glad I didn't. I like being alive, and no matter how much Lucy likes where you all are, now, I shouldn't want to be there.
Oh, Ed, I could never keep a secret from you. I suppose I'll just come out with it, then: You'll hate me for saying this, but I wish you could leave Aslan's country. Lucy's faith is unwavering; to sever her from that land would be her undoing. Peter - I shan't talk about Peter. But when she told me you were no longer curious - that you no longer fought to understand what made people do the great and terrible things they do, that you no longer craved learning more, that you lost your hunger - my heart fell. Who are you, without your passion and inquisition? From what little Lucy told me, I fear Aslan's country has made you smaller. She said no one wants for anything there. That you have everything you need, and so you don't think to need anything. The Edmund I remember would hate that. We shared greater struggles than our siblings, and so striving toward our goals became as important as reaching them. ██████████ █████████ ███████ Who is Edmund Pevensie without the joy of working to some end? Who is Edmund Pevensie when he wants for nothing?
(Please don't think that I wish you wanted for anything. I have found myself in a queer little world where most everything is supplied for us - but there is still room to learn and grow. I believe you'd be suited for this sort of world ever so much more than how Lucy described Aslan's country.)
I did not say this enough when you were alive: I love you, Edmund. I think often of when you were a child, and I would read to you, back even before we first went to Narnia. I hope it has occurred to Lucy to tell you that I have met some of the characters from those story-books: Sirs Lancelot, Sagramore, and Galahad come to mind. Sir Galahad reminds me of you, even though you are very different people, and Sir Lancelot is a very dear █████ friend to me.I think I lo I care very much for him. You'd like him ever so much. He's quite handsome. I imagine you'd appreciate that he's quite handsome.
I do so wish we could have discussed that, too. I believe you might have had homosexual tendencies, like me, like me. But by the end we weren't discussing much at all, were we? I wasted so much time, forgetting Narnia. I shan't let myself regret it - you of all people know my policy on regret, though you disagreed heartily with it the few times we spoke about it. Oh, Ed, I miss fighting with you ever so much. It was never heartbreaking or horrible, like when Lucy or even Peter got cross or disappointed with me. You wanted me to fight back, and you gave as good as you got. With the others, when Narnia came up, I always felt absolutely horrid. Like I was shaming them in some awful way; like they were condescending to me. You just wanted me to defend my positions. You always seemed so heartbroken about it, but you didn't make me bear your heartbreak. You never accused me of only caring about lipstick and nylons and invitations, because you bothered to fight with me about it, and learned of my classes and my job and - yes - my friends and my dates. You let me explain that my world was more expansive than just one way of being.
I suppose I'm the heartbroken one now. When they asked me to identify your body, I almost couldn't, there was so little there. Sometimes when I close my eyes and try to remember you, it's all I can see. They'd washed the blood off, but I could still tell where it had gone. Your face ██████ ████████████ Perhaps it's good that I still didn't remember Narnia when I went to that morgue. If I'd known then that Lucy's drops were real, I rather think I would have ripped the world apart at the seams to get at them. Aslan once lectured Lucy for spending too much time on you when you were injured during that first battle, do you remember? -Did we ever tell you? Ed, it was never a waste. Aslan was wrong, so terribly wrong. If I had Lucy's cordial, I'd have put a drop on every injury I could see, and if that didn't bring you back to life, I would have yelled at Aslan himself until he struck me down.
I have to write you first, you see, because you'll be the least disappointed at how furious I am with Aslan. You'll just want me to defend my position, as usual. My position is this: I hate what he's done with you. You died, and in so dying, you've become someone who isn't yourself, anymore. Lucy will always be faithful little Lucy who loves Aslan with her whole heart, but you and I, we had questions. We had goals. We had journeys and destinations. I'd hate to rip you out of Heaven, but can it truly be a Heaven if you must be re-molded to fit in there?
And if you truly believe that it suits you... well. I can't help but wish you could come here, even for an hour, and defend your position to me. That you can't means that I shan't ever forgive Aslan. Honestly, Ed, I hope there's some way that you'll some day be able to get furious with me for saying so.
Love,
your silly big sister,
Susan
Dearest Edmund,
Forgive me for saying so, but yours was not the most difficult death to swallow. And yet, the implications of what came after are the hardest for me to accept.
We were never the favorites, you and I. That was Lucy, with her fair shining hair and her reputation as the Valiant; that was Peter, who was the eldest and
Oh, but that's not the point of this letter, is it? There's no need to point fingers. Let's see: In your honor, I am trying to be more stubborn. I think I might be succeeding. I believe ██████████████ ███████████████████ █████████████████████ █████████████████, but as it turns out, I had it in me all along.
Lucy visited! Several months ago now. I do hope she told you. I do hope she hasn't forgotten. The picture she painted of Aslan's country was- I haven't the words to describe my reaction, but it seems as if earthly cares, like your dear living sister, mightn't be at the forefront of your mind any more. If she told you, then you'll know now that I've remembered everything about Narnia. I'm sorry to you in particular that I forgot for so long - and you know how I am about apologies. On the one hand, I do wish I could have remembered before you died, so that we could have spoken about it together without fighting. On the other hand, I'm glad I didn't. I like being alive, and no matter how much Lucy likes where you all are, now, I shouldn't want to be there.
Oh, Ed, I could never keep a secret from you. I suppose I'll just come out with it, then: You'll hate me for saying this, but I wish you could leave Aslan's country. Lucy's faith is unwavering; to sever her from that land would be her undoing. Peter - I shan't talk about Peter. But when she told me you were no longer curious - that you no longer fought to understand what made people do the great and terrible things they do, that you no longer craved learning more, that you lost your hunger - my heart fell. Who are you, without your passion and inquisition? From what little Lucy told me, I fear Aslan's country has made you smaller. She said no one wants for anything there. That you have everything you need, and so you don't think to need anything. The Edmund I remember would hate that. We shared greater struggles than our siblings, and so striving toward our goals became as important as reaching them. ██████████ █████████ ███████ Who is Edmund Pevensie without the joy of working to some end? Who is Edmund Pevensie when he wants for nothing?
(Please don't think that I wish you wanted for anything. I have found myself in a queer little world where most everything is supplied for us - but there is still room to learn and grow. I believe you'd be suited for this sort of world ever so much more than how Lucy described Aslan's country.)
I did not say this enough when you were alive: I love you, Edmund. I think often of when you were a child, and I would read to you, back even before we first went to Narnia. I hope it has occurred to Lucy to tell you that I have met some of the characters from those story-books: Sirs Lancelot, Sagramore, and Galahad come to mind. Sir Galahad reminds me of you, even though you are very different people, and Sir Lancelot is a very dear █████ friend to me.
I do so wish we could have discussed that, too. I believe you might have had homosexual tendencies
I suppose I'm the heartbroken one now. When they asked me to identify your body, I almost couldn't, there was so little there. Sometimes when I close my eyes and try to remember you, it's all I can see. They'd washed the blood off, but I could still tell where it had gone. Your face ██████ ████████████ Perhaps it's good that I still didn't remember Narnia when I went to that morgue. If I'd known then that Lucy's drops were real, I rather think I would have ripped the world apart at the seams to get at them. Aslan once lectured Lucy for spending too much time on you when you were injured during that first battle, do you remember? -Did we ever tell you? Ed, it was never a waste. Aslan was wrong, so terribly wrong. If I had Lucy's cordial, I'd have put a drop on every injury I could see, and if that didn't bring you back to life, I would have yelled at Aslan himself until he struck me down.
I have to write you first, you see, because you'll be the least disappointed at how furious I am with Aslan. You'll just want me to defend my position, as usual. My position is this: I hate what he's done with you. You died, and in so dying, you've become someone who isn't yourself, anymore. Lucy will always be faithful little Lucy who loves Aslan with her whole heart, but you and I, we had questions. We had goals. We had journeys and destinations. I'd hate to rip you out of Heaven, but can it truly be a Heaven if you must be re-molded to fit in there?
And if you truly believe that it suits you... well. I can't help but wish you could come here, even for an hour, and defend your position to me. That you can't means that I shan't ever forgive Aslan. Honestly, Ed, I hope there's some way that you'll some day be able to get furious with me for saying so.
Love,
your silly big sister,
Susan